William Keith Thomas v Joseph Fenton, Richard Fenton and Albertha Ryan
| Jurisdiction | Montserrat |
| Court | High Court (Montserrat) |
| Judge | ‘Morley J’ |
| Judgment Date | 05 March 2018 |
| Neutral Citation | MS 2018 HC 2 |
| Docket Number | CASE MNIHCV 2013/0017 |
| Date | 05 March 2018 |
IN THE EASTERN CARIBBEAN SUPREME COURT
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUSTICE
Morley, J.
CASE MNIHCV 2013/0017
(Executor of the estate of Peter William Molyneaux, deceased)
(as personal representative of Mary Ryan, deceased)
Mr David Brandt for the claimant.
Mr Ralph Francis for the defendants.
Will - Actual undue influence — Presumed undue influence — Whether actual undue influence arose — Whether the Will was made in suspicious circumstances — Whether the Will was valid — Section 7 Wills Act, Cap 3.08.
On Montserrat, by a Will dated 05.05.10, the claimant (Keith 2) was appointed executor of the estate of the deceased (Peter), who, born 12.02.29, died aged 84 on 28.03.13. The Will left his personal property and possibly many parcels of land, in Davy Hill, Sweeneys, and Thatch Valley, valued in all on 15.04.13 at $4053699.84 3, to his carer since 2006 Donarene Lewis (Donna) also known as Faye, and her young daughter Shaneil Jones (Shaneil), then aged under 10. As part of the terms of the Will, the land was to be developed by Keith who is a civil engineer and chartered surveyor.
Peter had a nephew living adjacent to his home on Davy Hill, named Richard Fenton (Richard). Also, there is a niece named Albertha Ryan (Albertha) in Dorchester, US, and a nephew in St Thomas, USVI, named Joseph Fenton (Joseph). The niblings got nothing and were quickly suspicious that Peter's Will was invalid as ‘not made voluntarily, was made in suspicious circumstances, and/or procured by means of undue influence’. When Keith on 12.04.13 announced his intention to file for probate, Joseph and Richard filed on 22.04.13 a caveat against grant, and when probate was applied for on 26.04.13, Peter's aunt Mary Ryan filed a caveat on 05.06.13, (who later died within five months on 17.09.13 and was replaced in the action by Albertha on 30.09.13).
In response to the caveat, on 24.07.13 Keith applied to the High Court by fixed date claim form that the caveats be removed and that he be granted probate to execute the terms of the Will.
Despite in the past a history of schizophrenia, testamentary capacity has been conceded.
I have to decide if the Will was made under undue influence and the burden is on Richard, Joseph and Albertha to show it was. In parallel, I also have to decide if there were suspicious circumstances, and the burden is on Keith to show there were not.
If the Will is set aside, then Peter will have died intestate, meaning the niblings and possibly other blood relatives might inherit his estate under s4 Intestates Estates Act 2002 cap 3.04, Donna and Shaneil get nothing, and Keith will not develop the land as executor.
Over many years, Peter had a history of mental health issues which, though explored by the defendants, it was accepted did not mean he had lacked testamentary capacity. He had no children he knew, though thought he might have a son in the UK he had never met. He was one of five siblings all now dead, leading to his being uncle to 18 niblings.
In 2006, in Davy Hill he took in as tenants Donna and Shaneil, from Jamaica: he lived downstairs and they lived upstairs. Over time a relationship began, he moved upstairs into a twin room, there being a bedroom for each person, and Donna became his carer.
Keith met Peter in November 2009. Peter was then 80. He wanted to develop land he had assiduously acquired over the years, registering his title at the Land Registry. Keith's skills meant he could help. The plan was to turn land at Sweeneys into many residential plots, for which Keith would put in a road, water, electricity, and bring the plots to a point where they could be sold for high value as poised for home building. In addition, he wished to develop land at Thatch Valley which in April 2010 he showed Keith on three occasions, by walking 2.5hrs into the wilderness over rough ground, which Keith videoed in part, seen by the court, showing Peter to be lively and sprightly, though with a limp.
On 03.05.10, within weeks of the Thatch Valley adventure, Peter asked Keith to recommend a lawyer to write his Will. Keith recommended his friend Kharl Markham (Kharl), whom he had met in the 1990s as musicians. Kharl spoke with Peter alone, who had been brought to his offices by Keith and Donna. Peter said to him he wanted to leave all his property to Donna and Shaneil, and Kharl noted Peter was particularly fond of ‘the little girl’. He was asked about his living relatives, mentioned a ‘Steve’ in prison, his possible son, and made no mention of his niblings, in particular saying nothing of Richard who was his neighbour. He appointed Keith as his executor, unknown to Keith, who while honoured, was not asked, nor informed by Kharl at the time as to the solemnity and seriousness of executorship. Peter wanted the land developed, directing in his Will specifically:
-
a. in para 5, that ‘all arrangements, understandings and agreements which I entered into with my Executor and Trustee Mr William Keith Thomas of Olveston Montserrat pertaining to the development and sale of lands at Sweeneys continue following my death’; and
-
b. in para 6, that ‘Mr William Keith Thomas continue all aspects of the management of my land at Thatch Valley Montserrat to include but not limited to entering into agreements for the sale of the said land with third parties after consultation’ with Donna.
Kharl did not tell Peter that he was an unpaid non-executive director in Keith's construction company Axuum (and Keith thinks also in Keith's planning company KTech).
Keith began work. He drew up plans for Sweeneys, paid for by being given a block of land worth $60000. Planning permission was granted on 07.07.10. Keith then cut a concrete road of 500m into the side of steep scrub, visited by me and the parties on 04.12.17, employing up to 20 persons, arranging for water and electricity, and erecting a shoring wall and safety barrier. To finance the work, Peter began selling plots of land, monies went in to his account at the St Patrick's Credit Union, and his account history shows that some monies were paid out to Axuum for work done.
This regular financial activity, while Peter was declining in mobility, though still sharp of mind, meant that to make running his affairs easier he decided to grant a legal power of attorney to Keith, first of a general nature on 10.02.11, and second specifically to do with his dealings in land on 01.03.11, both drawn up by Kharl.
Later as his health declined, on 22.06.12, nine months before he died, and no longer able to sign his name, he signed an ‘x’ to an agreement with Keith to carry out ‘infrastructure services’ at Sweeneys, again drawn up by Kharl.
Various affidavits have been offered in the case, from Keith, Kharl, the Credit Union, the Land Registry, Richard, Joseph, Albertha, and supporters of the niblings, but nothing from Donna. The niblings drew attention to her being paid $2400 per month to care for Peter, and yet believed she had neglected him, as he had bedsores when finally taken to hospital in March 2013 where he died six days later, on enquiry his clothes had disappeared, and there are moments they recall of his being controlled by Donna and denied their company.
In the end, when Peter died the land development project stopped. Keith claims he is still owed about $320000 for work done. The caveats stopped Peter's plans for the work to continue after his death, and stopped Keith being paid, while the case has now taken 4.5 years to come on.
In a sense, I must decide on balance what has occurred here: was the land development and bequests to Donna and Shaneil Peter's dream to benefit Shaneil and equally her mother of whom he had grown deeply fond; or was it a cynical attempt by Keith, with Kharl's dishonest help, to exploit the declining years of someone who was wealthy in land terms, to give Keith overpaid work, and to make an exploitative Donna possibly rich, having overborne Peter's mind as a captive to get him to leave all to her.
There was a trial on 04 and 06.12.17, during which I heard evidence from Keith, Kharl, Richard, Albertha, Joseph, and Monica Williams, and I visited the Sweeneys. In particular on 04.12.17, I watched and paid careful attention to the video and pictures filed by Keith on 29.10.13 as exhibit KT3 4 of Peter and Keith in April 2010 venturing together into the ruggedness of Thatch Valley, and noted the presence during one such visit, on 08.05.10, of Donna and Shaneil, which importantly is three days after Peter signed his Will in their favour. Closing argument took place on 06.12.17, with liberty to file supplemental submissions by 11.12.17, leading to further filing from Counsel Brandt for the claimant, but nothing from Counsel Francis for the defendants.
Peter's medical notes (being 155 pages) were disclosed by Dr Krishnamurthy Gopal and filed on 15.10.13 and 15.11.13. On analysis, they disclose a diagnosis of schizophrenia in 1988 and 1997, with mention of his believing ‘people were shooting at him’ in 2008. He suffered a stroke
in October 2011 and January 2013, and when admitted to hospital on 20.03.13, he profoundly lacked lucidity, suffering dementia and dehydration, and had significant foul-smelling bedsores which ultimately led to sepsis and contributed to his death, interalia from further stroke, on 28.03.13. Joseph in evidence recalled how Peter was interested in voodoo, and was suspicious of a person touching him, suggesting some mental illness. However, there has been no argument advanced by counsel at trial that his earlier diagnosis of mental illness plays any role in these proceedings, or that at the time he made his Will...Get this document and AI-powered insights with a free trial of vLex and Vincent AI
Get Started for FreeUnlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations
Unlock full access with a free 7-day trial
Transform your legal research with vLex
-
Complete access to the largest collection of common law case law on one platform
-
Generate AI case summaries that instantly highlight key legal issues
-
Advanced search capabilities with precise filtering and sorting options
-
Comprehensive legal content with documents across 100+ jurisdictions
-
Trusted by 2 million professionals including top global firms
-
Access AI-Powered Research with Vincent AI: Natural language queries with verified citations